Menu

Conference on the future of 2.Dh5

2.Dh5, 22 January 2017 in Moira, Utrecht

Conference on the future of 2.Dh5

No festival this time: one day to take stock of 2.Dh5 and the movement, and to decide what comes next.

On Sunday 22 January 2017, about 25 people met at the Moira in Utrecht.

After eleven editions we organised no festival that year, but a conference. With regular visitors and critics we wanted to take stock: where does the movement stand, and does a festival like 2.Dh5 still have a role in it?

Why a conference

After the edition in Maastricht, in February 2016, we were for the first time not satisfied with what the festival had to offer. After ten years we found it ever harder to connect with the movements of our time, or to be part of them. We saw this not only at 2.Dh5, but across the left, anti-authoritarian movement.

The movement had become smaller. There were few visible campaigns beyond the familiar squats and former left strongholds, and more and more activists went to work for trade unions and NGOs. At the same time, just outside what we conveniently called ‘our movement’, a lot was happening: a strong anti-racist movement, grassroots feminism, people organising around migration and refugees, climate, neighbourhoods, education and other forms of economy. We were hardly part of any of it.

The festival itself was stuck as well. It was meant as a platform for other groups, but more and more of the programme was filled in by the organising group itself. Discussions stayed at an introductory level, and every year it got harder to find people and places willing to carry the festival with us.

2.Dh5 stands for the second move in a game of chess: white moves the queen to h5. An opening on the left, but a lost strategy if the opponent pays a little attention. Were we in the same kind of dead end with 2.Dh5? We put that question to people and groups in the movement. Their written responses formed the basis of the conference.

The programme

  • 10:30 Doors open
  • 11:00 Welcome and introduction
  • 11:15 Plenary discussion ‘Movement analysis’: the radical spectrum, its influence and where things stand
  • 12:15 Plenary discussion ‘Aims of 2.Dh5’
  • 13:30 Lunch
  • 15:00 Theme discussions in small groups: two rounds of 50 minutes
  • 17:00 Feedback from the groups
  • 18:00 Drinks

The theme discussions

Everyone chose three of these six themes and joined the discussion on two of them. Afterwards each group presented, in two minutes, a scenario for the future of 2.Dh5: a plan, a piece of advice or a solution. Consensus was not required.

  • Connection. 2.Dh5 is largely white and male. Workshops on racism and sexism at most made that one workshop a little more diverse; a real connection with anti-racist and feminist groups did not follow. How have other groups managed it?
  • Growth. After eleven festivals we had not grown; if anything we had shrunk. There is a steady core and a changing group of first-time visitors, few of whom come back. What would it take to grow into a bigger festival with more impact on the movement?
  • A breath of fresh air. Can one festival draw both newcomers and experienced activists, or does 2.Dh5 have to choose?
  • The ideology of the eighties. Much of the organising group was active in the early 1980s, or took its cue from those years. Are our ideas and analyses too steeped in that time: small autonomous groups exercising power in the street with specific forms of action? And what fits today?
  • Away from the grand narratives; towards concrete steps. Should we think more in concrete projects that increase our influence, are of practical use and fit in with the rest of our lives?
  • Down with 2.Dh5! Is a festival nostalgia, a party with friends? Perhaps the focus on a festival and on being a fixed group of our own is the very obstacle. Should we come up with something completely different?

What came out of it

We mostly took inventory and did not aim for conclusions everyone agreed on, so some of the advice contradicts other advice. Five of the six themes were discussed in groups.

Already in the discussion about the aims of 2.Dh5, people said the festival should also pay attention to forms of resistance other than actions and campaigns, such as resistance in education and culture.

Connection

That 2.Dh5 is white and mostly male showed in who came to the conference. Start with awareness, for instance with a meeting about privilege and other forms of self-education. Make it less noncommittal: commit to breaking this pattern, work actively towards a change of culture, and say so publicly.

Involving groups that are not white takes more than inviting them to give a workshop. Build a relationship of trust: approach groups actively and take part in their activities, also apart from 2.Dh5. Talk with groups that have done better at this. Some participants wondered whether this can work from the existing group at all, and whether a new, shared start would be better. In any case, aim for diversity among speakers, also beyond topics such as anti-racism and feminism.

Lower practical barriers as well. Make the festival more accessible to people with children (bring back a children’s programme) and to people with disabilities, and say so up front rather than only arranging it on request. Pay attention to inclusive language; choosing a new subtitle for the festival was one concrete piece of advice.

Growth

Promotion has to change. The infrastructure of the eighties, with many (squatted) places where people met and where you could leave flyers and posters, no longer exists.

A breath of fresh air

Choose a fixed venue, and think again about a whole weekend versus a single day. Ask groups from different cities to take on a specific task, instead of temporarily expanding the organising group with people from the host city.

Aim at people who are already active and at new activists. 2.Dh5 does not have to be an easy first step; that belongs at the local level. Build the programme up: explore one theme in depth, with an introductory workshop and one or more follow-ups. Depth, analysis and strategy should be central. Say beforehand what a workshop is for, so people know what to expect. Consider an open call for workshops, and choose deliberately between a broad programme and one built around one or a few themes.

The ideology of the eighties

This group talked mostly about using the history of movements. Make ‘lessons from the past’ and success stories, with an analysis of them, regular parts of 2.Dh5. Add discussions about forms of action, and room for self-reflection.

Away from the grand narratives

Contrary to the question as posed, the advice was more theory and analysis, not less: built from practical experience and tested against it again. That calls for a bigger role for the organising group, steering the content of the programme and keeping up relationships with people and groups beyond the festival. At the same time, 2.Dh5 is a good moment to exchange concrete steps, as long as they do not take over. Choose fewer workshops that serve the general aims, perhaps even one aim per edition.

What happened next

We carried on. In February 2018, 2.Dh5 took place in Amsterdam. What we did with the advice, and what we ran into, we wrote down in 2.Dh5 onder de loep (part 1) and part 2 (in Dutch).

Earlier editions

A different theme every year, often a different city, always its own artwork.